Let’s Rethink New Year’s Resolutions
Every January, we’re bombarded with messages urging us to reinvent ourselves. The “New Year, New You” mentality dominates the conversation, promising quick fixes or dramatic lifestyle overhauls. But let’s be honest – how often do these promises lead to lasting change? More often than not, they result in burnout, frustration, and guilt when the changes don’t stick.
I have been known, however, to come home from a post-holiday trip to the mountains or a tropical vacation feeling the need for a “gentle reset” after indulging a little more than usual and being out of my regular routine. But a complete overhaul? That’s never on my new year agenda.
Instead of attempting to change everything overnight, what if we focused on sustainable changes that build lasting habits? Across the country, there’s an amazing movement gaining momentum. People are listening to health advocates on popular podcasts and discussing ultra-processed foods and food-related chronic diseases. More and more, people are realizing they have more control over their health than they ever thought possible. Your “predisposition” or family history doesn’t have to define your path.
The Problem with Restrictive Resolutions and Fad Diets
Statistics show that most resolutions fizzle out by mid-February. Why? They’re often too restrictive, unrealistic, and lack joy. They just aren’t sustainable. For instance, studies show that about 50% of new gym memberships are canceled by the end of January. Even more surprising is that many memberships go unused throughout the year. Interestingly, group fitness classes show higher attendance rates, proving that community and accountability matter. This is so true – I have family members that wouldn’t dream of missing their yoga class with friends or skip their morning masters swimming – people expect to see you there and that’s super motivating! Eventually you get into a routine that is all yours and that community likely played a part to get you there. Drastic, solo resolutions often don’t work.
The restrictive nature of most diets results in disappointment and frustration. Yo-yo dieting can harm your metabolism, mental health, and overall well-being. I’ve heard clients say they just don’t want to think about food so much. Yet, restrictive diets force you to do just that, creating a cycle of guilt and bingeing that leaves you worse off than before.
Without understanding what a balanced, nourishing diet looks like, people are drawn to the latest fad. Many diets thrive on cutting out entire food groups or demonizing specific macronutrients, creating confusion about what “healthy eating” truly means. That said, as a functional nutritionist, I was trained in and see the immense value in helping someone through a temporary, guided elimination diet to get to the root cause of a specific health problem, to heal the gut or calm inflammation. These are not fad diets and these temporary changes often lead to a new and improved eating pattern focused on promoting health and feeling your best. For many people, however, a strict elimination diet is rarely necessary.
A Better Way: Learning to Add Instead of Restrict
What if, instead of focusing on what to take away each day, you learned to add foods to your diet? A positive, abundance-focused approach helps you build a nourishing and sustainable way of eating without feeling deprived. I’ve talked about this approach for a long time and will continue to promote this way of eating.
Nutrient-dense foods leave you feeling full, satisfied, and energized. For example, adding avocado to a salad for healthy fats, roasted chicken for protein, and quinoa for fiber can transform a basic salad into a satisfying, balanced meal. No need to cut out the bread from the meal, it’s possible you just don’t have room in your stomach to eat it because you’re so satisfied from your salad!
This approach changed my life. By incorporating protein, fat, and fiber into every meal, my health transformed:
- Clearer skin: Nutrient-dense foods reduced inflammation and provided essential vitamins and minerals.
- Fewer headaches: Balanced meals stabilized my blood sugar, preventing sugar crashes.
- Improved digestion: Fiber-rich foods supported gut health and reduced bloating.
- Better energy levels: A balanced diet helped prevent energy dips throughout the day.
Small Changes, Big Impact
Small, consistent changes can lead to significant improvements over time. These habits are easier to adopt and stick with, creating lasting momentum. Some small changes to consider:
- Start your day by drinking a glass of water
- Add an extra serving of vegetables to dinner
- Swap that afternoon sugary snack with some nuts and whole fruit
Focus on one meal at a time, like breakfast. A balanced breakfast sets the tone for the day and reduces cravings later in the day. Here are a few ideas:
- Oatmeal: Add chia seeds, almond butter, and fresh fruit for protein, fat, and fiber
- Smoothie: Blend spinach, Greek yogurt, berries, and a scoop of collagen protein powder
- Toast: Use Ezekiel bread topped with avocado, hemp seeds, and a drizzle of olive oil
James Clear writes in his book Atomic Habits – “Every small step you take is a vote for the person you want to become” – not just today but in the years ahead. Let’s celebrate progress, not perfection.
A Journey, Not a Resolution
This year, let’s embrace a journey of sustainable change. In the coming weeks, I’ll share blog posts that guide you through building lasting habits. Topics will include:
- How to structure balanced meals with protein, fat, and fiber
- Simplified meal planning tips to make healthy eating easier
- Overcoming the diet mentality and shifting toward abundance
Please feel free to share this post with a friend or family member who might need encouragement.
Cheers to good health,
Christina
Discover more from Food + Family + Friends
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
Amy Hardt
Loving these recent posts, sis!!! All the diets growing up only made me mistrust food and my own appetite, but since learning to cook, create balanced meals and smart snacks I’ve never had to think about weight again and fortunately, no major medical issues have developed either. Also yes, I show up to regular spin and kickboxing classes not for the calorie burn or even the endorphins, but for the great music and excellent company. Keep sharing these positive messages!
Christina Shoup
Aww.. thank you! Yes, a diet is usually a lose lose situation – making real food at home is one of the biggest things ways to move the needle toward a life of good health as well as balanced meals and smart snacks. I’ll keep preaching this message all year long, not just in January!